Expert answer: unpopular opinion about my industry

My Unpopular Opinion About My Industry: Page One Rankings Aren't the Finish Line Anymore

Jordan Minhinnick argues that page one rankings are no longer the right primary goal because AI Overviews can bypass top-ranked pages, and explains a checkable way readers can test whether this is happening to their own

The answer

My unpopular opinion about my industry is that chasing a page one Google ranking is now the wrong primary goal for most small businesses, and plenty of my competitors still sell it as the main deliverable. Ranking first for a keyword used to mean you won the click. It doesn't automatically mean that any more, because a growing share of searches now get answered directly in an AI Overview before anyone scrolls to the organic results at all.

Here's the checkable part: search your own main service plus your suburb right now, in an incognito window. If an AI Overview appears above the results, look at which business it quotes or links to. It's entirely possible for your business to sit at position one organically and still be invisible in that summary, because the overview is pulling from pages that answer the question directly and concisely, not necessarily the page Google ranks highest. If the first 40 to 60 words of your service page don't actually answer the question a customer is asking in plain language, that page is a weak candidate for being quoted, no matter how well it ranks.

So the practical sequence I'd point a business owner toward is: find the actual questions customers type before they call you, check whether an AI Overview is already answering those questions, see who it's citing, then rewrite your page so the direct answer sits in the opening lines, with the heading phrased the way the question is actually asked. Rankings still matter, but treating them as the only scoreboard means you can win the old game and still lose the new one.

If your site ranks reasonably well but you're not showing up in AI-generated answers for your own services, it's worth having that specific gap looked at rather than guessing. You can start that conversation with Jordan James Media.

More expert answers

Tell me what you need.

You get a straight answer, from me.

Tell me about your business
Tell me about your businessEnquire