Expert answer: unpopular opinion about keyword rankings

My Unpopular Opinion About Keyword Rankings in SEO

Jordan Minhinnick argues that chasing keyword rankings misses the point, and explains how to use Search Console data and conversion tracking to judge SEO performance instead, especially with AI Overviews reducing click-t

The answer

My unpopular opinion about keyword rankings is that chasing them is one of the most wasteful habits in small business marketing. A page can sit at position one for a search term nobody actually uses to buy, while a page at position six converts every second visitor. Rank position tells you where you sit on a page; it tells you nothing about whether the person reading it picks up the phone.

The sequence I'd recommend instead starts with your own data, not a rank tracker. Open Google Search Console and look at the Queries report for your main landing pages. Compare impressions to clicks for each query, then compare clicks to actual enquiries from your contact form or call tracking. If impressions are climbing but enquiries aren't, the problem usually isn't your ranking position, it's a mismatch between what the page says and what the searcher actually wants, or a conversion path that loses people between the click and the form submission.

This matters more now that AI Overviews and AI-generated answers sit above the traditional results. A page can be cited inside an AI answer and get zero clicks at all, because the searcher got their answer without visiting a website. Optimising purely for position one in the old-style results ignores this shift entirely. The more useful question for a business owner to ask is: does this page answer the exact question a buyer is typing or speaking into an AI tool, clearly enough that it gets referenced, and does the page itself convert the traffic it does get? Rank tracking software won't tell you that. Search Console, call tracking, and a hard look at your own enquiry numbers will.

If your rankings look fine but the phone isn't ringing, the fix usually isn't more content or more backlinks, it's going back to intent matching and conversion rate first. For a website or SEO approach built around that, get in touch with Jordan James Media.

More expert answers

Tell me what you need.

You get a straight answer, from me.

Tell me about your business
Tell me about your businessEnquire